These are the claims that were tested and did not survive, and the ingredients that should not be in a supplement at all. This section exists on a site that carries affiliate links, which strikes some readers as a contradiction. It isn’t one, and the reason is worth two paragraphs of your time — starting with the rule that no page in this section has ever carried a product link, and none ever will.
Why a site with affiliate links publishes debunks
The straightforward answer: because the debunks are true, and a site that publishes only the findings compatible with its revenue is not a publication. Most of what is sold in this category does not work, several well-known ingredients have failed large well-run trials, and a handful are not lawful dietary ingredients in the first place. Those are the most useful facts we have. Withholding them to protect a commission would make every other page on the site worthless, because you would have no way of knowing which sentences had been edited by the accounting.
The structural answer: this section is walled off from monetisation by policy, not by good intentions. No debunk page carries an affiliate link, a product recommendation, a discount code or a “but try this instead” box. The same rule applies to interaction pages, side-effect pages, method guides, the category hubs and the red flags page. The pages that do carry links are labelled as such, disclose the commission above the link, and state the product’s worst fact inside the box rather than below it. The full arrangement is in our affiliate disclosure, and the process behind it is in our editorial policy.
There is also a plainer commercial logic, and we would rather state it than pretend to be above it. Readers can tell the difference between a site with a conclusion and a site with a funnel. A negative finding is the most valuable thing we can publish, and it is the reason anyone should believe the positive ones.
Claims that failed when they were tested properly
These are not cases of insufficient evidence. They are cases where somebody ran the trial, the trial was large enough and long enough to answer the question, and the answer was no.
- Ginkgo Biloba: Two Enormous Trials, Two Failures — the most-sold botanical in the category, tested at scale for prevention, twice, with null results both times.
- Prevagen and the Apoaequorin Verdict — an orally administered jellyfish protein, a post-hoc subgroup analysis, and a federal court that in December 2024 ordered the marketer to stop making the memory claims.
- Do Brain Training Apps Work? The FTC Has Opinions — the same story in software, with the same regulator and the same outcome.
- A Daily Multivitamin vs a Nootropic Stack — the inversion nobody in this industry wants to discuss: the one large multi-year trial with a positive, replicated cognitive result tested a supermarket multivitamin.
Ingredients that should not be in a supplement
A separate category, and a more serious one. These are not compounds with disappointing evidence — they are compounds that fail the legal definition of a dietary ingredient, or that cause harm at doses people actually take. We will never recommend anything in this group, in any dose, for any population.
- Racetams, Noopept and Phenibut: Sold Everywhere, Legal Nowhere — including the withdrawal syndrome that makes phenibut the most dangerous item routinely sold in this category.
- Why Vinpocetine Shouldn’t Be in Your Supplement — FDA’s position on its status, and the 2019 warning to women of childbearing age.
- Nine Ingredients That Signal a Bad Brain Supplement — the label shortcut, and what each of the nine tells you about who designed the formula.
- Vitamin B6 Toxicity — a vitamin, freely sold, causing sensory peripheral neuropathy at doses that appear in products bought for mental clarity.
The category, taken as a whole
Individual debunks are useful. The pattern they form is more useful, and these three pages are where we make the general argument rather than the specific one.
- The Case Against Brain Supplements (Written by a Site That Reviews Them) — the strongest version of the argument against the whole category, stated without hedging.
- Do Nootropics Actually Work? An Honest Tier List — the field ordered by evidence rather than by popularity, which turns out to be a very different order.
- Supplements That Cause Brain Fog — the inverted question, and the one almost nobody asks about their own stack.
What a debunk is not
It is not a verdict that nothing works, and it is not contrarianism for its own sake. Several compounds in our A–Z have real, replicated, small effects in specific populations, and we say so with the same directness we use here. A debunk is narrower than that: a specific claim, tested, found wanting, with the trial named. When new evidence goes the other way we will update the page and say what changed — that is the standard we hold the industry to, so it is the one we hold ourselves to.
Related reading
- Nootropics A–Z — every compound, tiered, including the ones that work
- Evidence Guides — safety, interactions and how the industry sells
- Without Supplements — what to do instead, and why we make nothing from it
- How We Rate the Evidence
- Affiliate Disclosure — where a commercial link may and may not appear
- Start Here
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Nothing here is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
This article is information, not medical advice. Talk to a doctor or pharmacist about your own situation, especially if you take prescription medication.
